Thursday, 17 October 2013

Paul McCartney, Charlotte Church, Lena Dunham, and Others Weigh In on the Great Miley Debate

Is Miley Cyrus a victim of the male gaze and the sexual
commodification of young women ... or a heroine of third-wave
feminism?
Is the former Hannah Montana a woeful example of how today's female
stars are willing to sell out their own bodies and souls in one
package deal ... or a victim of "slut-shaming"? Is she the new Elvis
... or just the new Linda Lovelace?
And when Rihanna takes to the stripper pole in her new video, is she
giving in to the public's appetite for leering, or sticking her tongue
out (to put it in Miley-esque terms) at sexists who don't want woman
to be sexual at all?
If you're looking for a definitive answer to these questions, don't
look to their fellow celebrities, who are caught up in an
international debate that mirrors the one going on in homes around the
country.
At first it looked as if the arguments about whether Miley is a
righteous champ or pathetic victim might break down along
generation-gap lines. Elder stateswomen Sinéad O'Connor and Annie
Lennox penned open letters criticizing Cyrus and/or her handlers in
the wake of her controversial VMAs performance. Then a rush of younger
artists jumped in to defend her, whether in intellectual terms (Amanda
Palmer) or, well, less so (Kelly Osbourne).
But as the weeks progress — and someday, we may divide history not
into B.C. and A.D. but before and after the Great Twerking Incident of
2013 — we've seen more youngsters come out against Miley and more old
farts rise up in her defense. You can hardly keep track of who thinks
she's a self-made role model and who's convinced she's a self-whoring
tramp without a scorecard.
Paul McCartney is the latest elder to weigh in on the "she's just
being Miley" side.
"Mind you, I've got a 10-year-old girl, so we listen to that kind of
stuff," the former Beatle told Sky News, asked about whether he pays
attention to teen pop. On the matter of Miley at the VMAs, he said,
"You know what, I don't think it was explicit at all. You couldn't see
anything. I mean, I watched it, just as an experiment, to check …
Obviously, you look at it and you go, What's everyone shouting about?
I mean, she's a young girl; she's like only 20 or something. She's
just having a go. Someone said to me that the world that a lot of
those people like Miley live in is all noise and you've got to rise
above the noise, so you've got to do something. So you will see people
doing something that I think is only mildly socking. I mean, she's
dancing with Robin Thicke on the Billboards, and so what? Come on.
We've seen worse than that!"

No comments:

Post a Comment

place your comments here